“If the federal government truly believes that health care is a right, not a business, as the Liberal Party campaigned on in spring 2025, then the federal government needs to immediately initiate the formal review of Bill 11 under the Canada Health Act.”
Who’s the Boss? Is your doctor in charge of your health care? Are you? Who really has oversight and accountability into the care you receive? Part 3 of my series on physicians looks at accountability and quality oversight in the system…and it’s more limited than we all might expect! Learn more on my substack. Bradenmanns.substack.com canadianhealthcare canadianphysicians quebecphysicians quebechealthcare medicare
The law firm Goldblatt Partners describes the changes introduced by Bill 11 as “the most extensive privatization of payment for medically required physician services since the Canada Health Act’s enactment in 1984.”
They add that it “permits queue-jumping and creates a parallel private pathway for the provisions of medically necessary care to insured residents of Alberta, contrary to the core objectives and provisions of the Canada Health Act.”
Photo by www.kaboompics.com: https://www.pexels.com/photo/plush-toy-in-top-of-blankets-4886897/
If you are in an emergency room on Vancouver Island and see carts being wheeled around filled with items such as blankets, neck pillows, and stuffed animals, you are probably in one of urgent care facilities that are implementing “Comfort Carts.” The single-use items on the cart are given to seniors as way to help individuals feel more comfortable as they wait to receive healthcare. “‘And gosh, does it ever feel good when you see the smile on a senior’s face, or the comfort, that look of relief when you provide those kinds of items to a senior in distress.'”
Image by Wim van ‘t Einde https://unsplash.com/photos/clear-glass-hour-glass-with-blue-liquid-iEhFJJAMTK4?utm_source=unsplash&utm_medium=referral&utm_content=creditShareLink
The Alberta Givernment claims that their dual practice will decrease wait times. Others, including medical associations, physicians disagree.
“‘Doctors across Canada are deeply concerned about the Alberta government’s proposal to expand private health care…This plan would take resources away from the public system and create a private option that only some people could afford. That would mean longer waits, fewer available doctors, and more strain on the public system, the one that most people depend upon.'”